Guide
Chargeback management: how to handle disputes as a seller
By Byron Kiriibwa · Updated
Managing chargebacks means handling every dispute the same way: see it the day it arrives, know its deadline, decide honestly whether it's worth fighting, answer the ones that are with the evidence the reason code asks for, and learn from each outcome. A routine keeps deadlines from slipping past and shows you where the next dispute will come from.
Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.
New to this? What is a chargeback? How it works, and what it costs
1. Know when one arrives
Your payment platform emails you and shows the dispute in its dashboard. Make sure those emails reach someone who reads them every day, because the response window starts at once. Some disputes, mostly from American Express and Discover, start as an inquiry asking for information before a chargeback: satisfactory evidence can settle it, and on Stripe and Shopify so can a full refund (a partial refund can still turn into a chargeback).
2. Track each deadline
Write down the due date for every open dispute and work to the earliest. The due date is final: miss it on Stripe and the dispute counts as lost.
Deadlines and fees
- Stripe (US): Respond by the due date on the dispute in your Stripe Dashboard. It's usually 7 to 21 days, depending on the card network. $15 when the dispute arrives, which isn't returned. $15 more when you respond, returned only if you win in full.
- Square: Seven days from Square's first email about the dispute. No fees for dispute management on chargebacks: Square covers the fee for disputes you challenge together.
- Shopify Payments (US): Respond by the evidence due date in your Shopify admin. It's usually 7 to 21 days. $15 per chargeback, returned if you win.
Checked 2026-10-21, from each platform's own pages.
Fees compared: Chargeback fees: Stripe, Shopify, Square and PayPal compared
3. Read the reason code
Every chargeback carries a reason code from the card network, such as Visa 13.1 or Mastercard 4853. It says what the cardholder claims, and so what the bank will check: delivery for an order that "never came", the terms the customer agreed to for a cancellation, signs the real customer made the purchase for a fraud claim.
Every code explained: Chargeback reason codes: Visa, Mastercard, Amex and Discover
4. Decide whether to fight, honestly
Not every chargeback is worth fighting. Accept it when the customer is right, when you don't have the evidence the reason code asks for and can't get it before the deadline, when the amount is less than responding costs you in fees and time, or when it looks like real fraud on a stolen card. Once a formal dispute is open, accept rather than refund: a separate refund can mean paying the customer twice.
The fight-or-accept calculator shows what a win gains and a loss costs on your amount and platform.
5. Gather the evidence the code asks for
Answer what the bank checks for that code, with dated records: tracking and delivery confirmation for goods; access and usage records and the terms accepted for digital products and subscriptions; proof the work was done for services; and your messages with the customer. Attach the records themselves, as screenshots or PDFs, since banks don't open links. Stripe allows 4.5 MB in total, and no more than 19 pages for a Mastercard dispute.
6. Respond once, and on time
Send one clear response through the platform the payment came from, before the due date. On Stripe a submission is final: you can't edit it or add files afterwards, so put everything in it and check it before you send.
How to fight a chargeback, step by step · How to respond to a Stripe dispute, step by step
7. Record the outcome
The bank usually takes 60 to 75 days to decide, and your platform shows the result. Keep a simple log of every dispute: the reason code, the product, what you sent, and how it ended. Record losses and accepted disputes as carefully as wins; together they show which kinds of dispute you win, and which aren't worth the fee.
8. Watch your dispute rate
Your dispute rate is disputes against payments, and every dispute counts, won or lost. Stripe says the industry treats dispute activity above 0.75% of payments as excessive. The card networks' own monitoring programs start higher, with minimum counts, but a platform can step in sooner. Check yours in your payment platform's dashboard each month.
9. Prevent the next one
Look at what customers claimed and fix the cause: a charge they didn't recognize, terms they didn't see, a parcel with no tracking, a subscription that was hard to cancel. Prevention is the only thing that keeps your dispute rate down.
Where Upheld fits
Upheld keeps this routine in one place. For a US business, connect Stripe and its disputes arrive on their own with their deadlines; from anywhere else, you add a dispute by hand. Either way you get emails 5, 3 and 1 days before the deadline, a list of the evidence that fits its reason code, a draft response, and an honest read on your case: a weak case is called weak, and accepting is offered. Nothing will be sent until you approve that specific response. For Stripe, Upheld then sends it and the result comes back on its own; otherwise you download it as a PDF to submit yourself, and we ask how it went 45, 60 and 75 days after you submit.
- Stripe: live for US businesses: disputes arrive on their own, and Upheld sends the response you approve
- Square: opens next; add its disputes by hand until then
- Shopify: in progress; add its disputes by hand until then
- Any other checkout: add the dispute by hand, which works today
Questions people ask
How do I manage chargebacks?
As a routine, the same for every dispute: notice it the day it arrives, note its deadline, read the reason code, decide honestly whether to fight or accept, gather the evidence that code asks for, respond once and on time, record the outcome, and watch your dispute rate each month.
What is chargeback processing?
The steps a chargeback goes through: the cardholder disputes a payment with their bank, the bank takes the money back from the business and holds it, the business responds with evidence or accepts, and the bank decides. Stripe says it can take two to three months from start to finish.
Should I refund a payment that's already disputed?
Usually not. Once a formal dispute is open, a separate refund can mean paying the customer twice; if the customer is right, accepting the dispute is the cleaner way to settle it. During an inquiry, before a chargeback, a refund may still be possible.
Does winning a dispute lower my dispute rate?
No. Every dispute filed counts toward your dispute rate, won or lost. Stripe says the industry treats dispute activity above 0.75% of payments as excessive; the card networks' own programs start higher. Only preventing disputes keeps the rate down.
Sources
- Stripe: how disputes work
- Stripe: responding to disputes
- Stripe: measuring disputes
- Stripe: dispute pricing update
- Square: manage payment disputes
- Shopify Help Center: the chargeback process
Checked 2026-10-30.
Got a chargeback to answer?
Answer a few questions about it and get a response built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach and an honest read on whether it's worth fighting.