Guide
Chargeback rebuttal letter example, and how to write one
By Byron Kiriibwa · Updated
A chargeback rebuttal letter is the written response you send with your evidence. The strongest ones read like a checklist the bank can tick: the reason code and amount, then one short paragraph for each thing the bank checks, each pointing to the exhibit that proves it.
Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.
The layout
- 1. Opening: The reason code, the amount, the date of the charge, and in one sentence what you contest.
- 2. One paragraph per thing the bank checks: Strongest evidence first. Each paragraph states a fact, names the exhibit that proves it, and ends with what it shows.
- 3. Closing: What the evidence shows, in one or two sentences, and the request that the dispute be decided in your favor.
A full example (made up)
A customer orders a $95 stoneware dinner set on March 3, with delivery promised by March 10. On March 8 you email that the order is delayed and will arrive by March 15, and the customer replies that the new date is fine. The carrier delivers it to the order's address on March 14. On March 28 the customer files a 13.1 dispute saying it never came.
We contest this dispute, Visa reason code 13.1, for $95.00 charged on March 3 for a stoneware dinner set. The customer received the order at the address they gave, by the delivery date they agreed to.
Why it's there: The opening names the reason code, the amount, the date and what was sold, then says in one sentence what you'll show. A reviewer reads this first.
The order was delivered to the customer's address. The carrier's tracking record shows delivery on March 14 to the full shipping address on the order (Exhibit C), the address the customer entered at checkout (Exhibit A).
Why it's there: The first thing the bank checks for 13.1 is delivery to the cardholder's address. The paragraph states that fact with its date, names the exhibit that proves it, and ties the address to the one the customer entered.
Delivery came by the date the customer agreed to. The order confirmation promised delivery by March 10 (Exhibit A). On March 8 we told the customer in writing that the order was delayed and would arrive by March 15, and the customer replied that the new date was fine (Exhibit B). The order arrived on March 14.
Why it's there: The second check is delivery by the promised date. Same pattern: the promise (Exhibit A), the date it arrived, and the shipping email that told the customer.
The order reached the address the customer gave, before the new date they accepted in writing. We ask that the dispute be decided in our favor.
Why it's there: The closing says what the evidence shows in one sentence and asks for the decision. It adds no new facts.
Attached:
- Exhibit A: the order confirmation, with the full shipping address and the promised delivery date of March 10.
- Exhibit B: your March 8 email about the delay and the new date of March 15, and the customer's reply accepting it.
- Exhibit C: the carrier's tracking record, showing delivered on March 14 to the full address on the order.
Weak sentences, and what to write instead
Made up, from the same example.
Instead of: The customer is lying. They obviously got the boots.
Write: The carrier delivered the order to the customer's shipping address on June 6, with a photo at the door (Exhibit B).
A fact with a date and an exhibit persuades; an accusation doesn't, and reviewers discount it.
Instead of: Please see the attached documents.
Write: The order confirmation promised delivery by June 9 (Exhibit A).
Say what each exhibit proves. The reviewer shouldn't have to work it out.
Instead of: Our boots are excellent and thousands of customers love them.
Write: The listing described the boots as brown leather, size 9 (Exhibit A), and the packing record shows that pair was shipped (Exhibit C).
The bank compares what was promised with what was delivered. Reviews and reputation aren't evidence.
Instead of: Tracking: https://carrier.example/track/1Z999
Write: The carrier's full tracking record is attached as Exhibit B.
Banks don't open links. Attach the record as a file.
Instead of: The customer probably received it.
Write: The tracking record shows delivery to the address on the order (Exhibit B). The carrier took no photo for this delivery.
Say plainly what you don't have. A guess weakens the facts around it; a gap stated honestly doesn't.
What your letter must answer, by reason
The layout stays the same; the paragraphs answer what the bank checks for the dispute's reason. One paragraph for each:
The customer says they didn't make this purchase
- Was the payment authenticated (3D Secure)? If so, liability usually sits with the bank, and Stripe adds the 3DS result to the evidence automatically.
- Is there a history linking this cardholder to the seller — earlier undisputed payments from the same customer, IP address, device, or account?
- Did the purchase go somewhere the cardholder controls — their billing address, their email, their login?
- Did the cardholder use what was bought after the charge?
The customer doesn't recognize the charge
- Does the statement descriptor clearly lead to this seller?
- Is there proof the cardholder made the purchase (same evidence as fraud)?
The customer says they didn't receive what they paid for
- Proof of delivery to the cardholder's address, or proof that access was granted and used, or proof that the service took place.
- That delivery happened by the date promised.
The customer says it wasn't as described or was defective
- How the product or service was described at the time of sale, compared with what was delivered.
- Whether the seller responded to the complaint and offered a fix, replacement, or return.
- For goods, whether the cardholder tried to return them.
The customer says they cancelled but were still charged
- That the recurring terms were clearly disclosed and agreed to at signup.
- Whether and when the customer cancelled, compared with the charge date.
- Whether the customer kept using the service after the charge.
- For trials and introductory offers, whether the required reminder was sent before the first full charge.
The customer says a refund was promised but not given
- The refund policy the customer agreed to at purchase.
- What the seller actually told the customer about a refund.
- Whether a refund or credit was already issued.
- For goods, whether a return was received.
The customer says they were charged twice
- Whether each charge is for a separate order, item, or billing period.
- Whether one of the charges was already refunded.
Do
- Keep it to facts you can attach, each with a date.
- Name every exhibit (Exhibit A, B, C) and attach it as a file.
- Answer each thing the bank checks for the reason code, strongest evidence first.
- Keep it short enough to read in two minutes.
Don't
- Paste links: banks don't open them. Attach screenshots or PDFs.
- Argue that the product was good in a fraud dispute: the question there is who made the purchase.
- Include the customer's full card number, or anything you can't show.
- Write in anger or blame the customer.
Example letters by reason code
Each guide ends with a sample letter for its code.
- Amex A01 chargeback (amount exceeds authorization)
- Amex A02 chargeback (no valid authorization)
- Amex A08 chargeback (authorization approval expired)
- Amex C02 chargeback (credit not processed)
- Amex C04 chargeback (goods returned or refused)
- Amex C05 chargeback (goods or services cancelled)
- Amex C08 chargeback (goods or services not received)
- Amex C14 chargeback (paid by other means)
- Amex C18 chargeback (no-show or deposit cancelled)
- Amex C28 chargeback (canceled recurring billing)
- Amex C31 chargeback (goods or services not as described)
- Amex C32 chargeback (damaged or defective goods)
- Amex F10 chargeback (missing imprint)
- Amex F24 chargeback (no cardmember authorization)
- Amex F29 chargeback (card not present)
- Amex F30 chargeback (EMV counterfeit, card present)
- Amex F31 chargeback (lost or stolen card, chip and PIN)
- Amex FR2 chargeback (Fraud Full Recourse Program)
- Amex FR4 chargeback (Immediate Chargeback Program)
- Amex FR6 chargeback (Partial Immediate Chargeback)
- Amex M01 chargeback (chargeback authorization)
- Amex M11 chargeback (reversal due to credit)
- Amex M36 chargeback (see notes): how to answer it
- Amex M38 chargeback (reversal)
- Amex M42 chargeback (reversal request too late)
- Amex OP1 chargeback (general dispute code)
- Amex P01 chargeback (unassigned card number)
- Amex P03 chargeback (credit processed as charge)
- Amex P04 chargeback (charge processed as credit)
- Amex P05 chargeback (incorrect charge amount)
- Amex P07 chargeback (late submission)
- Amex P08 chargeback (duplicate charge)
- Amex P22 chargeback (non-matching card number)
- Amex P23 chargeback (currency discrepancy)
- Amex R03 chargeback (insufficient reply to inquiry)
- Amex R13 chargeback (no reply to inquiry)
- Amex S01 notice (reversal request denied)
- Amex S04 notice (reversal request under review)
- Discover AA chargeback: unrecognized charge on a statement
- Discover AP chargeback: charged after cancelling
- Discover AT chargeback: payment not properly approved
- Discover AW chargeback: amount changed from what was agreed
- Discover CD chargeback: refund posted as a sale
- Discover DP chargeback: charged twice for one purchase
- Discover IN chargeback: invalid card number
- Discover LP chargeback: payment settled too late
- Discover PM chargeback: customer says they paid another way
- Discover RG chargeback: customer says it never arrived
- Discover RM chargeback: customer disputes the quality
- Discover RN2 chargeback (credit not processed)
- Discover UA01 chargeback (card-present fraud)
- Discover UA02 chargeback (card-not-present purchase denied)
- Discover UA05 chargeback (chip counterfeit)
- Discover UA06 chargeback (chip and PIN)
- Mastercard 4807 chargeback (warning bulletin file)
- Mastercard 4808 chargeback (authorization-related)
- Mastercard 4831 chargeback (transaction amount differs)
- Mastercard 4834 chargeback (point-of-interaction error)
- Mastercard 4837 chargeback (no cardholder authorization)
- Mastercard 4841: cancelled recurring or digital goods
- Mastercard 4842 chargeback (late presentment)
- Mastercard 4846 chargeback (wrong currency code)
- Mastercard 4849 chargeback (questionable merchant activity)
- Mastercard 4853 chargeback (cardholder dispute)
- Mastercard 4854 chargeback (US cardholder dispute)
- Mastercard 4855 chargeback (goods or services not provided)
- Mastercard 4860 chargeback (credit not processed)
- Mastercard 4863 chargeback (doesn't recognize the charge)
- Mastercard 4870 chargeback (chip liability shift)
- Mastercard 4871 chargeback (chip and PIN, lost or stolen)
- Visa 10.1 chargeback (EMV counterfeit card fraud)
- Visa 10.2 chargeback (lost or stolen card, chip and PIN)
- Visa 10.3 chargeback (card-present fraud, keyed sale)
- Visa 10.4 chargeback (fraud, card not present)
- Visa 10.5 chargeback (Visa monitoring programs)
- Visa 11.1 chargeback (Card Recovery Bulletin)
- Visa 11.2 chargeback (declined authorization)
- Visa 11.3 chargeback (no authorization, late presentment)
- Visa 12.1 chargeback (late presentment)
- Visa 12.2 chargeback (incorrect transaction code)
- Visa 12.3 chargeback (incorrect currency)
- Visa 12.4 chargeback (incorrect account number)
- Visa 12.5 chargeback (incorrect amount)
- Visa 12.6.1 chargeback (duplicate processing)
- Visa 12.6.2 chargeback (paid by other means)
- Visa 12.7 chargeback (invalid data)
- Visa 13.1 chargeback (merchandise or services not received)
- Visa 13.2 chargeback (cancelled recurring transaction)
- Visa 13.3 chargeback (not as described or defective)
- Visa 13.4 chargeback (counterfeit merchandise)
- Visa 13.5 chargeback (misrepresentation)
- Visa 13.6 chargeback (credit not processed)
- Visa 13.7 chargeback (cancelled merchandise or services)
- Visa 13.8 chargeback (original credit not accepted)
Questions people ask
What if I don't have evidence for one of the bank's checks?
Say so plainly and answer the checks you can. A claim you can't show weakens the rest of the letter. If you can't answer most of what the bank checks, accepting the dispute may cost less than fighting it.
Should the letter repeat what the customer said?
Only enough to show you understood the claim, usually the reason code and one sentence. The space is better spent on the facts that answer it.
Is a rebuttal letter the same as a dispute response?
Yes. Platforms call it a response, a rebuttal or a representment. It's the written explanation sent with your evidence.
How long should it be?
Usually under a page. One short paragraph for each thing the bank checks is enough when each points to its evidence.
Can I use the same letter for every dispute?
No. What the bank checks depends on the reason code, so the paragraphs change with it. The layout stays the same.
Get a letter written for your dispute
Answer a few questions and get a response in this layout, built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach. Free.