Visa 10.4 — Other Fraud — Card-Absent Environment

Visa 10.4: the cardholder says they didn't make this online purchase

By · Updated

Checked by three automated reviewers (facts against the playbook, search, and our rules), then approved by the author on .

Visa 10.4 means the cardholder says they didn't make a card-not-present payment. Visa doesn't allow it after Visa Secure authentication, and Compelling Evidence 3.0 answers it: two earlier undisputed payments on the same card, 120 to 365 days back, matching on two details, one of them IP address or device. If you believe it was fraud, accept, whatever the history.

Start a free draft

The bank's test

The bank checks:

  1. Was the payment authenticated with 3D Secure? If so, fraud liability usually sits with the card issuer.
  2. Does anything link this cardholder to the seller: earlier undisputed payments, the same IP address or device, the same account or email?
  3. Did the purchase go somewhere the cardholder controls: their billing address, their email, their login?
  4. Did the cardholder use what was bought?

Evidence that answers it

“Where it goes” uses the names Stripe's and Square's APIs give each piece of evidence, which are the names Upheld uses in your packet. Nothing is sent without your approval; where Upheld can't send it for you, you submit it yourself. In Stripe's Dashboard, choose the matching type for each file or text field. In Square's, add it when Square asks you to “upload any additional evidence specific to your service type”.

Evidence for Visa 10.4, by kind of business
EvidenceWhen it countsHow to show itWhere it goesFor
3D Secure authenticationIf the payment was authenticated.State that the payment was authenticated with 3D Secure and the result. For fraud disputes this usually moves liability to the bank.Stripe: Uncategorized text. There's no field of its own: for a payment that shifts liability, Stripe adds the 3D Secure result itself, so mention it in your letter.Square: Authorization documentationEvery seller
Earlier payments from the same customerShowing the same customer paid before without disputing.List each earlier payment with date and amount, and which identifiers match the disputed one (email, IP, device, shipping address, account).Stripe: Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 or Uncategorized textSquare: Related transaction documentationEvery seller
Customer IP address and deviceShowing the IP address or device matches earlier activity.Give the purchase IP and show the same IP or device on logins or earlier orders.Stripe: Customer purchase IPSquare: Cardholder informationEvery seller
Customer account historyShowing the account is tied to the cardholder's email.Account creation date, email, login count and dates, earlier orders. A screenshot or export from the seller's platform.Stripe: Uncategorized file or Uncategorized textSquare: Cardholder informationEvery seller
Messages with the customerShowing messages from the cardholder's email about this order.The relevant messages only, dated, with the key lines highlighted or quoted in the response.Stripe: Customer communicationSquare: Cardholder communicationEvery seller
Address and security-code checksShowing the address and security-code results, as supporting detail only.Report the check results as Stripe recorded them. Supporting evidence only, never the main argument.Stripe: Uncategorized text. There's no field of its own: mention the address and card code results in your letter.Square: Authorization documentationEvery seller
Proof of deliveryShowing delivery to the billing address or an address used on earlier undisputed orders.The carrier's delivery record showing date, address, and any signature or photo.Stripe: Shipping documentationSquare: Proof of delivery documentationOnline stores
Billing and shipping addresses matchThe order was sent to the cardholder's own billing address or a previously used address.Show both addresses side by side.Stripe: Billing address or Shipping addressSquare: Cardholder informationOnline stores
Access granted or digital product deliveredShowing it was sent to the cardholder's email.The delivery or welcome email, or the platform record showing when access was granted and to which email.Stripe: Access activity log or Customer communicationSquare: Online or app access logCourses, memberships, digital products
Access and usage logShowing use from the same IP address or device as the purchase.Dated list of activity tied to the customer's account: first and last login, count of sessions, what was viewed or downloaded. A short summary first, then the export.Stripe: Access activity logSquare: Online or app access logCourses, memberships, digital products
Service deliveredShowing the cardholder attended or received the work.Dates of service with proof: calendar invites and attendance, call records, delivered files, project sign-off.Stripe: Service date or Service documentationSquare: Service received documentationServices
Signed contract or agreementShowing the agreement is in the cardholder's name.The signed document with the signature and the relevant clauses marked.Stripe: Customer signature or Service documentationSquare: Purchase acknowledgementServices

Start a free draft

What doesn't help

  • An address or security-code match on its own; it shows the buyer had the card details, not that they were the cardholder.
  • Proof of delivery to an address, email, or account with no link to the cardholder.
  • Arguing that the product was good. In a fraud dispute the question is who made the purchase, not its quality.

Visa's rules for 10.4

  • Compelling Evidence 3.0 (Visa 10.4 only): at least two earlier transactions on the same payment method, paid and undisputed (not validation charges), 120–364 days before the disputed one, all processed by Stripe. They must match the disputed transaction on two main elements (purchase IP; device fingerprint or device ID, not both) or one main plus one secondary (shipping address, email address, customer account ID). Source: Stripe docs, checked 2026-10-06.
  • Visa's own CE 3.0 rule (Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules, 24 October 2026, section 11.8.5.3; read 2026-10-29): for disputes processed from 24 October 2026, the two earlier undisputed transactions on the same card (or a token for it) may have been at one or more merchants, processed more than 120 days before the dispute was submitted and no more than 365 days before it. Device ID and device fingerprint count as one element, not two. Stripe can show only payments it processed for this seller, so its eligibility check stays the one to follow.
  • 3D Secure: if the payment was authenticated, liability generally shifts to the issuer. Stripe adds the authentication result (ECI) to the evidence automatically. Visa doesn't allow 10.4 for a payment authenticated with Visa Secure (ECI 5 with a CAVV), or for an attempted authentication (ECI 6 with a CAVV) unless the card is a non-reloadable prepaid card.
  • Other cases where Visa doesn't allow 10.4: the issuer approved the payment although the CVV2 was entered and didn't match; the issuer had already reported the card for fraud when it approved the payment; or the issuer has raised more than 35 disputes on the card in the past 120 days (from 24 October 2026 Visa counts them per payment credential, so a token for the card counts too).
  • Other Visa fraud codes in the same Stripe category: 10.1, 10.2, 10.3 (card-present, chip), 10.5 (Visa monitoring programs).
  • If the issuer challenges the seller's compelling evidence at pre-arbitration and any contact detail the seller gave matches the cardholder's on the issuer's records, the issuer must say it contacted the cardholder about the evidence and explain why they still dispute. So give every detail that matches the cardholder: full name, billing or shipping address, phone, email. For digital goods, Visa's compelling evidence asks for the date the goods or services were provided (it said downloaded before), which fits access and use records. Source: Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (24 October 2026), sections 11.3.2 and 11.6.1; read 2026-10-29.

Common mistakes with Visa 10.4

  • Sending delivery proof without explaining how the recipient connects to the cardholder.
  • Not collecting IP address, device, and email at checkout, so there is nothing to link the purchase to the cardholder.
  • Ignoring an authentication result that would have settled the dispute.

Should you fight it?

Fight it when the payment was authenticated with Visa Secure, when earlier undisputed payments on the same card match this one on two details, one of them its IP address or device, or when the cardholder used what was bought. Accept it when any of these is true:

  • No authentication and nothing at all linking this cardholder to any earlier activity.
  • Goods shipped to an address unrelated to the cardholder, with no other link.
  • Digital access granted but never used, and nothing else ties the cardholder to the purchase.
  • The seller suspects the order really was fraud. Accepting also avoids paying to fight a case that should be lost.

If you accept, don't refund as well: once it's a chargeback the money has already gone back to the customer, so a refund would pay them twice.

A dispute counts against your account whether you win or lose. To see the chance of winning at which fighting pays on your amount, try the fight-or-accept calculator; to compare what you keep with each tool, the fee calculator.

How to prevent the next one

  • Use 3D Secure for risky or high-value online payments (Stripe Radar rules can require it).
  • Collect email, billing address, IP address, and device data at checkout (Stripe Checkout or Stripe.js does this).
  • Deliver digital products through a login tied to the buyer's email, and log access.
  • For high-value goods, ship only to the billing address or a previously used address, with signature on delivery.
  • Use a statement descriptor customers will recognize.

Deadlines and fees

Deadlines and fees by platform
PlatformDeadlineFees
Stripe (US)Checked 2026-10-21Respond by the due date on the dispute in your Stripe Dashboard. It's usually 7 to 21 days, depending on the card network.$15 when the dispute arrives, which isn't returned. $15 more when you respond, returned only if you win in full.Stripe's Smart Disputes waives the $15 response fee and takes 30% of the disputed amount when you win.
SquareChecked 2026-10-21Seven days from Square's first email about the dispute.No fees for dispute management on chargebacks: Square covers the fee for disputes you challenge together.
Shopify Payments (US)Checked 2026-10-21Respond by the evidence due date in your Shopify admin. It's usually 7 to 21 days.$15 per chargeback, returned if you win.

A worked example (made up)

A customer has bought from your online store with the same account, card and email last September and November and again in March, none disputed. On May 4 the same account, from the same device and IP address as the September and November orders, buys a $64 order, delivered to the same address as before. Eighteen days later, on May 22, the cardholder tells their bank the May 4 order wasn't theirs.

The response would attach:

  1. Exhibit A: the customer's account record: when it was created, the email, and the shipping address on file.
  2. Exhibit B: the three earlier orders from this account on the same card, with dates, amounts and the same address, none disputed.
  3. Exhibit C: the device and IP address of the May 4 order, matching the September and November orders.
  4. Exhibit D: the carrier's record showing the May 4 order delivered to the account's saved address.

A sample response letter (made up)

For the example above. It's laid out the way Upheld drafts a response: one part for each thing the bank checks, strongest evidence first, each pointing to its exhibit. Yours should state only what your own records show.

We contest this dispute, Visa reason code 10.4, for $64.00 charged on May 4. The purchase was made from the cardholder's own account, on a device they had used before, and delivered to their usual address.

Two earlier undisputed orders on this card, last September and November, fall within Visa's 120-to-365-day window. The same account and card placed three earlier orders, last September and November and in March, with the same email and shipping address, and none was disputed (Exhibits A and B).

This order came from the same device and IP address as the September and November orders. The device and IP address of the May 4 order match the ones recorded on those orders (Exhibit C).

The order went to the address on the cardholder's account. The carrier delivered it to the same address as the earlier orders (Exhibit D).

The account, the card, the device and the delivery address all tie this purchase to the cardholder who made the earlier undisputed orders. We ask that the dispute be decided in our favor.

Questions people ask

What is a 10.4 chargeback?

The Visa code for fraud in a card-absent environment: the cardholder says they didn't authorize an online, phone or mail-order payment.

The address and security code matched. Is that enough?

No. Visa looks for Visa Secure authentication, or two earlier undisputed payments on the card that match this one on two details, one of them IP address or device. Delivery to the billing address or one used on earlier undisputed orders can also tie the cardholder to it.

Does 3D Secure help?

Yes. Visa doesn't allow a 10.4 for a payment authenticated with Visa Secure. Stripe adds the authentication result to the evidence itself; elsewhere, attach the authentication record.

What is Compelling Evidence 3.0?

Visa's rule for answering a 10.4 with history: at least two earlier paid, undisputed payments on the same card, more than 120 and no more than 365 days before the dispute, matching this one on two details, such as IP address and device, or one of those and the shipping address, email or account. On Stripe, follow its eligibility check: it counts only payments it processed for you.

Draft yours free

Answer a few questions and get a draft, an evidence checklist and an honest read on whether to fight. Free account, no card.

Not sure what your notice says? Decode it first.

Start a free draft