For memberships, communities, newsletters, and software
Answer "I cancelled" disputes with the records you already keep
Recurring billing draws more disputes than one-off sales. Most turn on three facts: what the member agreed to at signup, whether and when they asked to cancel, and whether they kept using what they paid for.
The disputes you'll see most, and what answers them
The member says they cancelled and were charged anyway.
What answers it
- The recurring terms they accepted at signup: price, interval, and how to cancel
- Your cancellation records, showing no request before the charge
- Logins or use after the disputed charge
- The renewal reminder you sent, for trials and introductory offers
When accepting is the better choice
They cancelled before the charge and were billed anyway, or a trial converted with no reminder.
The member doesn't recognize the charge, often an annual renewal.
What answers it
- How the name on their statement links to your brand and website
- Their subscription history and earlier undisputed payments
- The renewal receipt sent to their email
When accepting is the better choice
You can't link the charge to a known member.
The cardholder says they didn't sign up at all.
What answers it
- 3D Secure authentication, if the payment used it
- Earlier payments and logins from the same account, IP address, or device
- Activity tying the account to the cardholder's email
When accepting is the better choice
Nothing links the account to the cardholder, or you suspect real fraud.
Does it work with your billing platform?
Your own Stripe account
Stripe Billing, Memberful, Ghost, LaunchPass, Chargebee with Stripe, Recurly with Stripe
The dispute is in your Stripe Dashboard, so Upheld brings it in with its deadline.
LiveAny other checkout
PayPal, an invoice, or a platform that lets you answer its disputes
Add the dispute by hand, get the same draft, and send the PDF packet wherever your platform takes evidence.
Works todayThe platform is the merchant
Skool, Paddle
They're the merchant of record: the payment is taken on their account, not yours, so Upheld can't connect to it. Paddle answers chargebacks itself and doesn't accept evidence from sellers; the amount and its fee still come out of your balance.
Can't connectChecked against each platform's own help pages on 2026-11-05: Stripe Billing, Memberful, Ghost, LaunchPass, Chargebee with Stripe, Recurly with Stripe, Skool, Paddle.
Guides for your situation
- A subscriber disputed their annual renewal
- Charged twice after a failed checkout
- "I don't recognise this charge" on a digital product
- A digital download: the customer says they never got it
- A customer forgot to cancel the free trial
- A Ghost member disputed the charge
- A member says they cancelled, but never did
- A Memberful member disputed the charge
- The customer was promised a refund that never came
- You refunded the customer, and they filed a chargeback anyway
- A Substack subscriber disputed the charge
Questions
A member says they cancelled, but we have no record of it. Can I respond?
Yes. Show the recurring terms they accepted at signup, your cancellation records with no request before the charge, and their use after the charge. If they did ask to cancel before the charge and were billed anyway, accepting is usually the better choice.
Do I need to remind members before a renewal?
For free trials and introductory offers, Visa and Mastercard expect a reminder before the first full charge, with a way to cancel online. Without one, a cancellation dispute after a trial is hard to win.
How is this different from Stripe's Smart Disputes?
Smart Disputes builds a response from data Stripe already holds and charges 30% of the disputed amount when you win. Upheld asks for the evidence that lives outside Stripe, such as cancellation records, logins, and renewal reminders, shows you every sentence before anything is sent, and charges a flat price per dispute.
Does a won dispute still count against my account?
Yes. A dispute counts toward your dispute rate with Stripe and the card networks whether you win or lose, so preventing disputes matters as much as winning them.
Will Upheld send anything to the bank without my approval?
No. You read every sentence of the response, with the source of each fact beside it, and nothing is submitted until you approve it. For a connected Stripe account, Upheld sends it to Stripe once you approve; otherwise you download it and submit it yourself.
Have a dispute open now?
Get a draft built only from your answers, the evidence to attach, and an honest read on whether it's worth fighting. Free account, no card needed.
Draft a free response