Visa 13.2 — Canceled Recurring Transaction

A Substack subscriber disputed the charge

By · Updated

A Substack reader pays through the Stripe account you connected, so the dispute is yours to answer in Stripe, not Substack's. Most say the subscription was cancelled, which Stripe files as subscription canceled. Stripe asks you to show the subscription was active and the reader knew your cancellation procedure and didn't use it.

Start a free draft

What decides a Substack subscription dispute

It's your dispute, not Substack's
Substack's terms say it isn't a party to the transaction between a creator and a reader and is under no obligation to become involved in a dispute between them. The payment went through the Stripe account you connected, so the dispute notice and the deadline are in your Stripe dashboard.
Whether the subscription was still active
Stripe's own guidance for a subscription canceled dispute is to demonstrate that the subscription was still active and that the customer was aware of, and did not follow, your cancellation procedure. A reader who cancelled before the charge and was billed anyway has a point.
What the reader saw when they paid
Stripe's evidence form has a field for your cancellation policy as shown to the customer and one for how and when it was shown before purchase. Every Substack has a monthly and an annual plan, so the plan they picked and its renewal are part of what they agreed to.
Reading after the charge
Stripe accepts an acknowledgement of continued use after the date they claim they cancelled. Posts opened, comments or replies after the renewal are that acknowledgement. Reading from before the charge doesn't count.
One response, inside the window
Stripe gives you a limited window to respond, usually 7 to 21 days depending on the card network, and only one opportunity to submit; once sent, nothing can be added. A response that misses the window loses automatically.

The bank's test

The bank checks:

  1. That the recurring terms (price, interval, how to cancel) were clearly disclosed and agreed to at signup.
  2. Whether and when the customer cancelled, compared with the charge date.
  3. Whether the customer kept using the subscription after the charge.
  4. For trials and introductory offers, whether the customer was reminded before the first full charge.

Evidence that answers it

“Where it goes” uses the names Stripe's and Square's APIs give each piece of evidence, which are the names Upheld uses in your packet. Nothing is sent without your approval; where Upheld can't send it for you, you submit it yourself. In Stripe's Dashboard, choose the matching type for each file or text field. In Square's, add it when Square asks you to “upload any additional evidence specific to your service type”.

Evidence for Visa 13.2, by kind of business
EvidenceWhen it countsHow to show itWhere it goesFor
Recurring billing agreed at signupThe customer agreed to be charged repeatedly, at a stated amount and interval.The signup page or email showing price, interval, renewal, and how to cancel, with the date the customer signed up.Stripe: Cancellation policy disclosure or Uncategorized fileSquare: Purchase acknowledgementEvery seller
Subscription billing historyWhen the subscription started, each renewal, and that earlier renewals weren't disputed.Start date, plan, each charge date and amount, status.Stripe: Cancellation rebuttal or Uncategorized textSquare: Related transaction documentationEvery seller
Cancellation historyWhether, when, and how the customer asked to cancel, compared with the charge date, stating plainly if no request was received.A dated timeline: signup, renewals, any cancellation request and its channel, the disputed charge. State plainly if no request was received.Stripe: Cancellation rebuttal or Customer communicationSquare: Generic evidenceEvery seller
Use after the disputed chargeThe customer kept using the product or service after the charge they now dispute: logins or use after the disputed charge.Activity dated after the charge date, with the charge date stated for comparison.Stripe: Access activity log or Cancellation rebuttalSquare: Online or app access logCourses, memberships, digital products
Messages with the customerDepending on content: the customer acknowledged receipt, was satisfied, never asked for a refund or cancellation, or was offered a fix.The relevant messages only, dated, with the key lines highlighted or quoted in the response.Stripe: Customer communicationSquare: Cardholder communicationEvery seller

Start a free draft

What doesn't help

  • Recurring terms that appear only in a footer link or in general terms of service.
  • Use from before the disputed charge.
  • "They never emailed us" when customers could cancel in the app, and the app's cancellation records weren't checked.

Visa's rules for 13.2

  • Visa: 13.2 covers a recurring charge made after the cardholder withdrew permission to bill, or after the seller was told the account was closed. It doesn't apply to a payment the cardholder started themselves, an unscheduled card-on-file charge, an installment, or a payment the cardholder says was fraud. It doesn't apply when the cardholder cancelled after the disputed charge (a standing rule since 18 April 2026). The dispute is limited to the unused part of the service. Source: Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (24 October 2026), section 11.11.3; read 2026-10-29.
  • Visa's accepted responses: the cardholder asked to cancel from a later date and the service was provided until then; the seller bills after the service and the cardholder received it until the cancellation date; the cardholder used the service after withdrawing permission and before the dispute; the seller wasn't told the account was closed; a credit or reversal the issuer didn't take into account; the dispute is invalid; the cardholder no longer disputes it. The cancellation date is the last day the cardholder may use the service (told on 22 April they can use it to the end of the month, the date is 30 April).
  • Visa's rules for recurring charges: a simple way to cancel, online if the customer signed up online; the fixed dates or interval of the charges; the terms shown when the customer consents, apart from the general terms; and, at least 7 days before a charge when a trial, introductory, or promotional period ends, a notice by email or another agreed channel with the amount, the date, and an easy way to cancel online. Source: same rules, section 5.8.11.1 (Tables 5-19 and 5-20).
  • For trials that turn into paid charges, Visa also requires click-to-accept consent at checkout and a written confirmation straight after signup. Source: same rules, section 5.8.17.2. A seller who skipped these has no answer to that requirement, and a missed trial notice can be disputed as 13.5.

Common mistakes with Visa 13.2

  • Missing a cancellation request sent through another channel (chat, reply to a receipt, in-app).
  • Charging after a trial without sending a reminder first.
  • Making cancellation hard to find or impossible online.

Should you fight it?

Fight it when the reader never cancelled, your subscription records show the plan they chose and when, and they kept reading after the charge. Accept it when any of these is true:

  • The customer cancelled before the charge and was billed anyway.
  • The recurring terms weren't clearly disclosed at signup.
  • Cancelling required steps that were unreasonably hard, or couldn't be done online.
  • A trial or introductory offer converted to a paid charge with no reminder sent.

If you accept, don't refund as well: once it's a chargeback the money has already gone back to the customer, so a refund would pay them twice.

A dispute counts against your account whether you win or lose. To see the chance of winning at which fighting pays on your amount, try the fight-or-accept calculator; to compare what you keep with each tool, the fee calculator.

How to prevent the next one

  • Show price, interval, renewal, and how to cancel at checkout, with a box the customer ticks.
  • Email the terms right after signup.
  • Remind customers before renewals, and always before a trial converts.
  • Offer online cancellation (Stripe's customer portal does this), confirm every cancellation by email, and stop billing at once.

Deadlines and fees

Deadlines and fees by platform
PlatformDeadlineFees
Stripe (US)Checked 2026-10-21Respond by the due date on the dispute in your Stripe Dashboard. It's usually 7 to 21 days, depending on the card network.$15 when the dispute arrives, which isn't returned. $15 more when you respond, returned only if you win in full.Stripe's Smart Disputes waives the $15 response fee and takes 30% of the disputed amount when you win.
SquareChecked 2026-10-21Seven days from Square's first email about the dispute.No fees for dispute management on chargebacks: Square covers the fee for disputes you challenge together.
Shopify Payments (US)Checked 2026-10-21Respond by the evidence due date in your Shopify admin. It's usually 7 to 21 days.$15 per chargeback, returned if you win.

A worked example (made up)

A reader on your $50 annual plan renews on June 3. On June 24 a dispute arrives in Stripe with the reason subscription canceled. Your records show no cancellation, the reader opened eight posts between June 4 and June 22, and the renewal receipt went out on June 3.

The response would attach:

  1. Exhibit A: the checkout for the annual plan as the reader saw it, with the $50 yearly price and that it renews each year.
  2. Exhibit B: the subscription record: paid subscriber since the previous June, annual plan, renewed June 3, no cancellation at any point.
  3. Exhibit C: the renewal receipt emailed on June 3.
  4. Exhibit D: the eight posts opened between June 4 and June 22, each with its date.

A sample response letter (made up)

For the example above. It's laid out the way Upheld drafts a response: one part for each thing the bank checks, strongest evidence first, each pointing to its exhibit. Yours should state only what your own records show.

We contest this dispute, Visa reason code 13.2, for $50.00 charged on June 3, the yearly renewal of the customer's paid subscription to our publication. The subscription was active, the customer never cancelled it, and they kept reading after the charge.

The customer chose the annual plan a year earlier at a checkout showing the $50 yearly price and that it renews each year (Exhibit A). Our subscription record shows the plan, the renewal on June 3 and no cancellation before or after it (Exhibit B).

The customer was told of the charge the day it happened: the renewal receipt was emailed on June 3 (Exhibit C).

The customer went on using the subscription after the charge, opening eight posts between June 4 and June 22 (Exhibit D).

The charge was a renewal the customer agreed to, no cancellation was made, and the customer used what they paid for. We ask that the dispute be decided in our favor.

Questions people ask

Substack says it isn't involved. So who answers the dispute?

You do, in Stripe. Substack's terms say it is not a party to the transaction and won't become involved in a dispute between a creator and a reader. The notice, the evidence form and the deadline are all in the Stripe account you connected to your publication.

Can I accept the dispute and be done with it?

Yes, and it's the clean way out when the reader did cancel first. Stripe's dispute received fee applies either way, even when you accept. Don't send a refund on top: the disputed amount is already going back to the reader through the dispute itself.

The reader says they cancelled on Substack, but the renewal still went through.

Check the cancellation date against the charge date. Stripe lists a customer mistaken about the actual cancellation date, for instance one set for a future date, among the things worth explaining. If they cancelled before the charge and were billed anyway, accept it.

What does a dispute cost me on Stripe?

Two fees. The dispute received fee is never returned. The dispute countered fee, charged when you respond, is returned if you win. Stripe also says that even in the most favourable cases it's very difficult to overturn a disputed payment, so send everything you have the first time.

Draft yours free

Answer a few questions and get a draft, an evidence checklist and an honest read on whether to fight. Free account, no card.

Not sure what your notice says? Decode it first.

Start a free draft