Guide

How to fight a chargeback, step by step

By · Updated

To fight a chargeback, read the notice for its reason code and deadline, decide whether the case is worth fighting, gather the evidence that code asks for, and send one clear response through your payment platform before the deadline. The bank weighs your evidence far more than your argument, so the evidence is most of the work.

Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.

  1. 1. Read the notice

    Find three things: the reason code (such as Visa 13.1 or Mastercard 4853), the amount, and the date your response is due. The reason code decides what the bank checks; the due date is final. The notice decoder can find them for you.

    Deadlines and fees

    • Stripe (US): Respond by the due date on the dispute in your Stripe Dashboard. It's usually 7 to 21 days, depending on the card network. $15 when the dispute arrives, which isn't returned. $15 more when you respond, returned only if you win in full.
    • Square: Seven days from Square's first email about the dispute. No fees for dispute management on chargebacks: Square covers the fee for disputes you challenge together.
    • Shopify Payments (US): Respond by the evidence due date in your Shopify admin. It's usually 7 to 21 days. $15 per chargeback, returned if you win.

    Checked 2026-10-21, from each platform's own pages.

  2. 2. Decide whether to fight

    Accept the dispute instead when:

    • the customer is right: it never arrived, it was faulty, or you charged after they cancelled;
    • you don't have the evidence the reason code asks for, and can't get it before the deadline;
    • the amount is less than responding costs you in fees and time;
    • it looks like real fraud on a stolen card.

    The fight-or-accept calculator shows what a win gains and a loss costs on your amount and platform.

  3. 3. Gather the evidence the code asks for

    Every reason code comes down to a few questions. Answer those, with dated records.

    "I never received it"

    Decided on: Proof the customer received it, by the date you promised.

    Evidence: Delivery to the order's address; access set up for their account and used; the service performed.

    Guides: Visa 13.1 chargeback (merchandise or services not received) · Amex C08 chargeback (goods or services not received)

    "It wasn't as described" or "It was faulty"

    Decided on: What you promised at the sale against what you delivered, and whether you answered the complaint.

    Evidence: The listing as it was on the day of sale; your reply offering a fix, replacement or return.

    Guides: Visa 13.3 chargeback (not as described or defective) · Mastercard 4853 chargeback (cardholder dispute)

    "I didn't make this purchase"

    Decided on: Whether anything ties the real cardholder to the purchase.

    Evidence: 3D Secure; earlier payments they didn't dispute; the same device, email or account; use of what was bought.

    Guides: Visa 10.4 chargeback (fraud, card not present) · Mastercard 4837 chargeback (no cardholder authorization) · Amex F29 chargeback (card not present)

    "I cancelled" or "I was promised a refund"

    Decided on: The policy they agreed to at purchase, what you told them, and whether a refund was issued.

    Evidence: The terms as shown at checkout, with their agreement; your messages; the refund record if you refunded.

    Guides: Visa 13.2 chargeback (cancelled recurring transaction) · Visa 13.6 chargeback (credit not processed) · Visa 13.7 chargeback (cancelled merchandise or services)

  4. 4. Write the response

    Open with the reason code, the amount and the date, and say what you contest. Then one short paragraph for each thing the bank checks, strongest evidence first, each naming the exhibit that proves it. Close with what the evidence shows. Plain facts, no anger, nothing you can't attach.

    See a full example letter.

  5. 5. Send it before the deadline

    Submit through the platform the payment came from: the dispute in your Stripe Dashboard, Square's dispute page, or your Shopify admin. Attach each exhibit as a file. You usually get one response, so check it before you send.

  6. 6. Wait for the decision, and prevent the next one

    The card issuer decides, and your platform shows the result. Whatever it is, note what the customer claimed: clearer descriptions, delivery confirmation, and easy cancelling help prevent repeat disputes.

    Handling more than the odd one? See how to manage chargebacks as a routine.

Questions people ask

Does winning a dispute take it off my dispute rate?

No. A dispute counts toward your dispute rate whether you win or lose. Winning gets the money back; preventing the next dispute is what lowers the rate.

Can I send a link to tracking or to my website?

Attach the records themselves. Banks don't open links, so a tracking page or a product page has to be a screenshot or PDF, dated.

Should I refund instead of fighting?

Once a dispute is open, ask your payment platform before refunding: a separate refund on a disputed payment can mean paying the customer twice. If the customer is right, accepting the dispute is the cleaner way to settle it.

Can I respond more than once?

Usually not. Most platforms send one response per dispute, so put everything in it before you submit.

Draft yours free

Answer a few questions about your dispute and get a response built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach.