Guide
Square chargebacks: how to respond, and how to prevent them
By Byron Kiriibwa · Updated
When a customer disputes a Square card payment, Square holds the disputed amount from your balance straight away and emails you. You have 7 days from that email to refund the customer or challenge the dispute, with no dispute fee either way. If you challenge it, the bank can take up to 90 days to decide. A few payment types work differently, covered below.
Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.
1. Open the dispute
In your Square Dashboard, go to Orders & payments, then Disputes. The dispute has the bank's reason and an information request form. Look the reason code up in the reason-code list to see what the bank checks.
2. Refund, or challenge
If the customer is right, refunding settles it. If you have the records to show otherwise, challenge it: the money is already held, and Square charges no fee for a dispute you challenge together.
3. Attach what the form asks for
Square's form says what the bank needs for that reason. Collect it, attach it, then submit. What usually answers it:
- the itemized receipt, with your contact details on it;
- for shipped goods, the tracking and the delivery receipt;
- for a service, a signed, dated document of what was provided, with the customer acknowledging they received it;
- your return, refund and cancellation terms as the customer saw them;
- your messages with the customer.
4. Wait for the bank
Square sends your response to the bank. The bank can take up to 90 days from the start of the dispute to decide, and Square can't speed it up.
If you win, Square releases the held funds back to you, including the processing fees. If you lose, the held funds go to your customer and the processing fees for the payment aren't refunded. Square says the outcome is final once the bank decides, and that after a loss it can't keep challenging on your behalf.
When Square handles it differently
The steps above are for card payments. Square's own page lists four cases that work another way.
ACH payments: Square can't challenge
Square says that under NACHA rules it can't challenge an ACH dispute, and a seller can't contest an ACH reversal, which removes the funds from your Square account. You deal with the customer directly. Square says customers with consumer bank accounts can return a payment within 60 days of the original transaction, and customers with business accounts within 2 days.
Afterpay: Afterpay decides
Square says Afterpay decides whether the dispute is won or lost, and you can manage it from your Square Dashboard or your Afterpay Business Hub. Square says the review may take up to 30 days.
Cash App Pay: fraud disputes are covered
Square says a seller who gets a fraud dispute on a Cash App Pay payment is covered entirely by Square, owes no money and has to take no action. That applies only to Cash App Pay payments. Square says other Cash App Pay disputes follow its normal disputes process, where you can challenge with evidence and either win or lose.
Swiped chip cards: you cover the loss
Square says banks resolve disputes on swiped chip card payments in the customer's favor when the customer claims fraud, so you cover the loss. Square says chip cards provide a layer of protection against fraud when the card is dipped or tapped.
Upheld's drafting is built around disputes you can challenge with evidence, so it doesn't change how these four cases work.
Preventing the next one
Square's own advice:
- Set your customer-facing business name so it reflects what you sell, so the charge looks like you.
- Give an itemized receipt for every sale, with your phone number, address and website, so a customer can reach you before their bank.
- Show your return, refund and cancellation terms on receipts and agreements.
- Online, keep tracking and delivery receipts; for services, a signed record that the work was received.
- Use Risk Manager to catch online payments that look risky, with actions you choose.
Questions people ask
Does Square charge a chargeback fee?
No. Square says there are no fees for dispute management on chargebacks: it covers the fee for every dispute you challenge together.
Does Square have chargeback protection?
Not any more. Square ended its Chargeback Protection, which covered up to $250 of dispute losses a month, in 2019. It covers the dispute fee instead.
How long do I have to respond to a Square dispute?
For a card payment, 7 days from Square's first email about the dispute. That's your time to refund the customer or challenge it. ACH and a few other payment types work differently.
Can I challenge an ACH dispute on Square?
No. Square says that under NACHA rules it can't challenge an ACH dispute, and that unlike a card dispute a seller can't contest an ACH reversal. You have to deal with the customer directly.
What if a customer disputes a payment I took by swiping their chip card?
Square says banks resolve disputes on swiped chip card payments in the customer's favor when the customer claims their card was used fraudulently, so you have to cover the loss. Square says chip cards provide a layer of protection against fraud when the card is dipped or tapped.
How long does a Square dispute take?
If you challenge it, Square says the bank can take up to 90 days from the start of the dispute to decide.
How long a customer has to dispute: the time-limit calculator. Fees on other platforms: chargeback fees compared. Square's own help or a response tool: when each is enough.
Sources
- Square: manage payment disputes
- Square: prevent payment disputes
- Square: update about Chargeback Protection (2019)
Checked 2026-11-12.
Draft your response free
Answer a few questions about the dispute and get a response built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach. Upheld's Square connection is built and tested against Square's test system, and opens to sellers next; until then, add a Square dispute by hand.