Comparison

How to respond to a Square dispute, and when Upheld helps

Facts about Square checked 2026-10-28, from its own site. Sources are at the end.

Square already helps: it covers the fee for disputes it challenges with you, adds receipts and tracking when it has them, and, its developer docs say, challenges a dispute itself if you miss the deadline. What it can't add is evidence that lives outside Square: the course the buyer worked through, the terms they agreed to, the messages you exchanged. Upheld tells you what the bank checks for the reason and drafts the response from that evidence for you to approve; Square disputes are entered by hand until connecting Square opens, which comes next.

Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.

Upheld today: Connect Stripe (US businesses) and disputes arrive with their deadlines, and Upheld sends the response you approve to Stripe. Square opens next; Shopify is in progress. From anywhere else, you enter a dispute by hand (paste the notice or upload a screenshot of it) and download the finished packet to submit in your platform's dashboard. Prices: $9 a draft, or $29, $59 or $99 a month for 15, 60 or unlimited drafts. Your first 3 drafts are free. Every draft counts, drafting a dispute again included; editing the letter is free.

How to respond to a Square dispute

  1. Open the dispute: in the Square Dashboard, go to Orders & payments, then Disputes, and open the dispute's information request form.
  2. Answer within seven days of Square's first email. Seven days is short: enter the deadline with the dispute and Upheld reminds you 5, 3 and 1 days before it.
  3. Attach what answers the bank's question for the dispute's reason. Square adds what it holds, such as receipts and tracking numbers, when available; your own evidence is the rest.
  4. If the deadline passes with no answer, Square challenges the dispute for you with what it has.

Square and Upheld, side by side

SquareUpheld
Price"There are no fees for dispute management services for chargebacks — we cover the fee for every dispute that we work together to challenge."$9 a draft, or from $29 a month. Nothing more when you win.
If you do nothing"If the due_at deadline passes with no action from the seller, Square automatically challenges the dispute on the seller's behalf."Reminders 5, 3 and 1 days before the deadline. Nothing is sent without your approval.
Writing the responseIn the Dashboard, under Orders & payments, Disputes: you answer the form and attach the documents it asks for. Square says it adds information it holds, such as receipts and tracking numbers, "when available".Matches Square's reason for the dispute to what the bank checks for it (a few reasons use our general guide), lists the evidence that answers it for your kind of business, drafts the letter from your answers and files, and rates the case honestly.
SendingFrom the Dashboard, within seven days of Square's first email.You download the packet and answer in the Dashboard. Connecting Square opens next; then the response goes to Square after you approve it, and Square says it adds information it holds when available.

When Square is the better choice, and when Upheld is

Square

  • Square's receipts and records already answer the bank's question for the dispute's reason.
  • You'd rather not pay to answer a small dispute.
  • You're happy to write the response yourself in the Dashboard.

Upheld

  • Your evidence lives outside Square: delivery tracking, course access, signed terms, messages with the customer.
  • You want to know what the bank checks for the dispute's reason, and an honest read on whether to fight.
  • You'd rather not leave it to an automatic challenge with only what Square holds.

Questions for what you sell

The bank's test depends on the dispute's reason, and the evidence that passes it depends on what you sell. Upheld asks:

  • Courses and coaching: where the program is hosted (Kajabi, Teachable, Thinkific, Skool, Circle or your own site), how much of it the buyer used, and what your refund terms said when they bought.
  • Memberships and subscriptions: how members can cancel, whether a trial was followed by a reminder before the first full charge, and whether renewal receipts say how to cancel.
  • Physical goods: the carrier's proof of delivery, and where the order was shipped compared with the card's billing address.
  • Services billed online: what the client agreed to before paying, and how much of the agreed work was delivered.

Square: questions sellers ask

If Square challenges disputes for free, why use anything else?

Square adds information it holds, such as receipts and tracking numbers, when available. The bank decides on evidence for the dispute's reason, and for many reasons (an item not received, a cancelled subscription, a service the customer says they didn't get) the deciding evidence is often yours, not Square's.

Can I still use the Square Dashboard after Upheld sends a response?

Once sending to Square is switched on, no: Square says that once an app uploads and submits evidence, the seller can no longer act on that dispute in the Square Dashboard, and the Dashboard isn't updated. Upheld shows the dispute's status instead. Upheld uploads nothing to Square until you approve the response, so until then the Dashboard stays yours.

Try it on a dispute

Draft a response free: answer a few questions and get a letter built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach.