Comparison

Shopify chargebacks: Shopify Protect, Shopify's own response, or Upheld

Facts about Shopify checked 2026-10-28, from its own site. Sources are at the end.

Shopify already answers chargebacks for you: on Shopify Payments it writes a defense with AI from your order's details and sends it on the due date, and Shopify Protect covers fraud on eligible Shop Pay orders. Where it falls short is a dispute that order details can't answer: a course the buyer says they never used, a cancelled membership, a service. That's where Upheld comes in. Shopify isn't connected yet, so you enter the chargeback by hand and add your evidence in the Shopify admin. Your first 3 drafts are free.

Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.

Upheld today: Connect Stripe (US businesses) and disputes arrive with their deadlines, and Upheld sends the response you approve to Stripe. Square opens next; Shopify is in progress. From anywhere else, you enter a dispute by hand (paste the notice or upload a screenshot of it) and download the finished packet to submit in your platform's dashboard. Prices: $9 a draft, or $29, $59 or $99 a month for 15, 60 or unlimited drafts. Your first 3 drafts are free. Every draft counts, drafting a dispute again included; editing the letter is free.

How to respond to a Shopify dispute

  1. Find the chargeback in your Shopify admin; you usually have 7 to 21 days to respond.
  2. Check what Shopify adds on its own: the order's products, customer details, addresses, IP address, and shipping and tracking.
  3. Add the evidence the order can't show, before the due date: for a course, the buyer's progress; for a membership, the terms and how they could cancel; for a service, proof it was delivered.
  4. Submit, or let Shopify send on the due date. After evidence is submitted, Shopify doesn't let you change it.

Shopify and Upheld, side by side

ShopifyUpheld
Price$15 per chargeback in the US, returned if you win. Shopify Protect is "at no extra cost" and, on a protected order, covers the order and the chargeback fee.$9 a draft, or from $29 a month. Nothing more when you win.
Fraud chargebacks on Shop Pay"Shopify Protect covers the total order cost, chargeback fee, and handles the dispute process on protected fraud-based chargebacks." US stores only; eligible orders must be fulfilled within seven days with a tracking number from a supported carrier.Shopify handles a protected order; Upheld isn't needed for it.
Other chargebacks"a defense of your case is written for you by Shopify using AI", with the order's details (products, customer details, billing and shipping addresses, the order's IP address, shipping and tracking) added automatically, and sent for you on the due date (you can opt out of the AI insights); you can add evidence in the admin before then. You usually have 7 to 21 days to respond.Matches the dispute's reason to what the bank checks, lists the evidence that answers it for your kind of business, drafts the letter from your own answers and files, and rates the case honestly.
ConnectionYour Shopify admin, where the chargeback arrives.Shopify isn't connected yet: you enter the dispute by hand, draft it in Upheld, and add your evidence in your Shopify admin. Stripe connects today for US businesses; Square opens next.

When Shopify is the better choice, and when Upheld is

Shopify

  • It's a fraud chargeback on a Shop Pay order that Shopify Protect covers.
  • The order's details (delivery and tracking) answer the bank's question on their own.
  • You'd rather not copy a chargeback into another tool.

Upheld

  • You sell digital goods or services, where the order's details prove little.
  • You want to know what the bank checks for the dispute's reason, and an honest read on whether to fight.
  • You also sell through Stripe or Square and want all your disputes in one place.

Questions for what you sell

The bank's test depends on the dispute's reason, and the evidence that passes it depends on what you sell. Upheld asks:

  • Courses and coaching: where the program is hosted (Kajabi, Teachable, Thinkific, Skool, Circle or your own site), how much of it the buyer used, and what your refund terms said when they bought.
  • Memberships and subscriptions: how members can cancel, whether a trial was followed by a reminder before the first full charge, and whether renewal receipts say how to cancel.
  • Physical goods: the carrier's proof of delivery, and where the order was shipped compared with the card's billing address.
  • Services billed online: what the client agreed to before paying, and how much of the agreed work was delivered.

Shopify: questions sellers ask

Should I add evidence before Shopify's due date?

Yes, if your evidence isn't in the order. Shopify sends on the due date, and after evidence is submitted you can't change it.

My store doesn't use Shopify Payments. Does this apply?

No. Shopify Protect and Shopify's AI-written defense are for Shopify Payments. If your store takes payments through Stripe, PayPal or another processor, your disputes come from that processor; Upheld connects to Stripe today for US businesses, and Square opens next.

Try it on a dispute

Draft a response free: answer a few questions and get a letter built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach.