Comparison

Stripe Smart Disputes vs Upheld: 30% of each win, or a flat price

Facts about Stripe checked 2026-10-28, from its own site. Sources are at the end.

Smart Disputes is built into Stripe: it puts together a response mainly from the data Stripe holds (you can add your own evidence to it) and submits it before the deadline, for 30% of each dispute you win. Upheld charges a flat price, builds the response from your own evidence as well as Stripe's, and sends nothing until you approve it. Smart Disputes costs less on small disputes; Upheld costs less as the amounts grow.

Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.

Upheld today: Connect Stripe (US businesses) and disputes arrive with their deadlines, and Upheld sends the response you approve to Stripe. Square opens next; Shopify is in progress. From anywhere else, you enter a dispute by hand (paste the notice or upload a screenshot of it) and download the finished packet to submit in your platform's dashboard. Prices: $9 a draft, or $29, $59 or $99 a month for 15, 60 or unlimited drafts. Your first 3 drafts are free. Every draft counts, drafting a dispute again included; editing the letter is free.

Stripe Smart Disputes and Upheld, side by side

Stripe Smart DisputesUpheld
What it costs30% of the disputed amount for each dispute you win; nothing on a loss.$9 per draft, or a monthly plan. No share of what you win.
Stripe's $15 response feeWaived.Charged when you respond, and returned if you win in full.
Stripe's $15 fee when a dispute arrivesStill charged.Still charged.
Where the evidence comes fromData available to Stripe when the packet is made: Stripe's own data, your transaction data and cardholder data. You can add evidence to the packet, and adding a tracking number lets Stripe pull delivery data itself.Stripe's records of the payment, plus what the bank asks for in your kind of business: delivery proof for goods, login and progress records for courses, signed terms and cancellation records for memberships, messages with the customer.
SendingSubmits the packet on its own just before the deadline if you do nothing. You can turn auto-submit off in Stripe's settings.Nothing is sent until you approve that response.
Which disputesEligible card disputes. Stripe decides eligibility from the reason code, payment method, the evidence available, its relevance, and cost.Any dispute you add, including ones you enter by hand.
SetupYou enroll your account; no integration work, since it's built into Stripe.Connect your Stripe account, or enter a dispute by hand.

On your numbers

A win ofSmart Disputes takesUpheld's draft cost
$50$15$9, or $1.93 on Starter if you use all 15
$200$60$9, or $1.93 on Starter if you use all 15
$500$150$9, or $1.93 on Starter if you use all 15

Losses change it: Smart Disputes charges nothing on a loss, and Upheld charges for every draft, and you pay Stripe's $15 counter fee on a loss, which Smart Disputes waives. For example, if you win one dispute in three, Smart Disputes costs less across a month on disputes under about $190, and Upheld costs less above it. That assumes you'd win as often with either; if one wins more often for you, the point moves in its favour. The calculator works it out on your own numbers.

Your disputes each month

ToolMonthly costHow it adds up
Upheld$59Starter, plus Stripe's counter fee on 2 losses
Stripe Smart Disputes$15030% of 2 wins

Win count is your own estimate; we don't publish win rates until we have verified outcomes. Stripe's $15 dispute fee is the same everywhere and left out. Competitor rates last checked: Stripe Smart Disputes 2026-10-29.

A price that doesn't change with the outcome

A share-of-wins fee is paid only when a dispute is fought and won. Upheld's price is the same whatever happens, so it has no reason to tell you to fight a case you'll probably lose. When yours is weak, it says so and offers accepting as an option, which costs nothing more on Upheld. Work out whether a dispute is worth fighting.

When Smart Disputes is the better choice, and when Upheld is

Smart Disputes

  • Your disputes are small, so 30% of a win is a few dollars.
  • Stripe already holds the evidence that answers the claim.
  • You want no work at all, and a response sent even if you forget.

Upheld

  • Your disputes are larger, so a share of each win adds up.
  • What answers the claim lives outside Stripe, and you want the response built around it: delivery proof, course access logs, signed terms, messages with the customer.
  • You want to read and approve every response, and to be told plainly when a case isn't worth fighting.

Questions for what you sell

The bank's test depends on the dispute's reason, and the evidence that passes it depends on what you sell. Upheld asks:

  • Courses and coaching: where the program is hosted (Kajabi, Teachable, Thinkific, Skool, Circle or your own site), how much of it the buyer used, and what your refund terms said when they bought.
  • Memberships and subscriptions: how members can cancel, whether a trial was followed by a reminder before the first full charge, and whether renewal receipts say how to cancel.
  • Physical goods: the carrier's proof of delivery, and where the order was shipped compared with the card's billing address.
  • Services billed online: what the client agreed to before paying, and how much of the agreed work was delivered.

Smart Disputes: questions sellers ask

Can I use Upheld and Smart Disputes together?

Not on the same dispute: a dispute gets one response. If you answer a dispute yourself, Stripe charges its $15 fee for a response sent manually. On a Smart Disputes account, Stripe submits its own packet just before the deadline if nothing has been sent, so send yours first or turn auto-submit off in Stripe's dispute settings.

When is Smart Disputes the better choice?

For small disputes, and when you have nothing to add beyond what Stripe already holds. It costs nothing on a loss and waives Stripe's $15 counter fee, so across a month it often costs less on smaller disputes than a single win suggests: the example on this page works it out. It also needs no time from you.

Does either one guarantee a win?

No. The card issuer decides. Stripe says the same of Smart Disputes, and we don't publish win rates until we have verified outcomes of our own.

Try it on a dispute

Draft a response free: answer a few questions and get a letter built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach.