American Express S04 — Reversal Request Under Review

Amex S04: your request to reverse a chargeback is under review

By · Updated

Checked by three automated reviewers (facts against the playbook, search, and our rules), then approved by the author on .

Amex S04 means American Express is still reviewing the reversal request you already sent, so nothing has been decided and there's no new argument to make (unverified: the meaning comes from secondary sources). Check that the notice matches the request and credit you sent, keep those records together, and wait.

What an Amex S04 means for you

A review in progress
S04 reports that American Express is reviewing your request to reverse a chargeback. Unverified: the meaning is from secondary sources, and Amex's December 2024 US disputes guide doesn't list S04.
Matching the notice to your records
The notice should name the charge and the reversal request you sent. Lay it beside your copy of that request and the refund or credit record behind it.
Waiting for the decision
There's nothing to do but wait for the review. The request you already sent is what's being reviewed, so a fresh argument isn't called for.

The bank's test

The bank checks:

  1. Does the notice match what the seller did (a credit, a request, an authorization)?
  2. Has the payment already been refunded, or does the cardholder no longer dispute it?

Evidence that answers it

These are the records to keep with the notice. Nothing is sent while the review is open; “Where it goes” names the field each would use if you're ever asked to send it.

Evidence for American Express S04, by kind of business
EvidenceWhen it countsHow to show itWhere it goesFor
Refund or credit already issuedThe customer was already refunded or credited, in full or in part, with the seller's own record of the credit or request.Refund date, amount, and reference.Stripe: Uncategorized fileSquare: Generic evidenceEvery seller

What doesn't help

  • Evidence that answers a different question from the one the notice asks.

American Express's rules for S04

  • S04: a status notice: the seller's request to reverse a chargeback is being reviewed. Unverified: the title and meaning are from secondary sources read 2026-10-15; American Express's US disputes reference guide (December 2024) doesn't cover this code, and the full Merchant Rules haven't been read.

Common mistakes with American Express S04

  • Treating the notice as a new claim and writing a fresh rebuttal: it reports on a reversal request already sent.

What to do

Nothing in an S04 calls for a rebuttal. Compare it with your records: the charge it names, the reversal request you sent, and the refund or credit behind it. Then hold your refund record and your copy of the request together until the review is decided. There's no accept-or-fight choice to make while it's open:

  • Nothing to accept or rebut: wait for the review's decision.

How to prevent the next one

  • Keep a record of every credit, reversal request, and reply sent to American Express.

A worked example (made up)

You design websites for small businesses and bill online. A client pays a $900 deposit on April 2, then cancels before work begins, and you refund the full $900 to their card on April 9. A chargeback for the same payment arrives on April 25, and on April 28 you ask for it to be reversed, sending the refund record. In May you receive S04: the request is under review. You check the notice against your records, keep them together, and wait.

The seller keeps, with the notice:

  1. Exhibit A: the S04 notice, naming the $900 deposit and the April 28 reversal request.
  2. Exhibit B: a copy of the April 28 reversal request as it was sent, with its date.
  3. Exhibit C: the refund record: $900 back to the same card on April 9.

A sample record to keep (made up)

For the example above. Nothing is sent: it sets out what the review already has, so it's ready if the notice changes. Yours should state only what your own records show.

This record, kept with notice S04, sets out what the review covers; nothing new is sent. The notice concerns the $900.00 website design deposit charged on April 2 and our April 28 request to reverse the chargeback.

The notice matches our request. It names the $900.00 deposit and the reversal request we sent on April 28 (Exhibit A), and our copy of that request, as sent, is filed with it (Exhibit B).

The deposit was refunded before the chargeback. The full $900.00 went back to the same card on April 9, sixteen days before the chargeback of April 25 (Exhibit C).

The record is unchanged since our request. We wait for the review's decision.

Questions people ask

What does Amex S04 mean?

American Express is still reviewing the reversal request you sent, so it's a status update rather than anything new from the cardmember. Unverified: this meaning is from secondary sources, and Amex's US disputes reference guide (December 2024) doesn't cover S04.

Do we need to respond to an Amex S04?

There's nothing to do but wait for the review. Check the notice against the reversal request and the credit you sent, and keep those records where you can find them.

What records should we keep while an Amex reversal request is under review?

Your refund or credit record, your own copy of the reversal request, and every reply sent to American Express about the charge.