American Express P23 — Currency Discrepancy
Amex P23: the issuer says the payment was in the wrong currency
By Byron Kiriibwa · Updated
Checked by three automated reviewers (facts against the playbook, search, and our rules), then approved by the author on .
American Express P23 means the issuer says the payment was processed in the wrong currency. Amex lists only one response, a credit that offsets the charge, so unless you already refunded the payment, accepting is usually right. The charge's currency, and whether the cardmember chose any conversion, answer the issuer's question but aren't on Amex's list.
What decides an Amex P23
- Amex's single listed response
- Currency records aren't on Amex's list for P23: its US disputes guide names only a credit that offsets the charge. A refund you already made is that credit; currency records aren't on its list, so without a refund accepting is usually right.
- The currency the cardmember agreed to
- Outside Amex's list, the issuer asks whether the payment was processed in the currency the cardmember agreed to be billed in. A receipt in one currency and a processor's record in that same currency answer it.
- A conversion the cardmember chose
- Also outside Amex's list: if the price was converted, the issuer asks whether the cardmember chose that. The checkout record showing the currency displayed and the one picked is the evidence for it.
The bank's test
The bank checks:
- Has a credit that directly offsets the charge already been processed? It's the only response Amex lists for P23.
- Only if the seller contests outside Amex's list: was the payment processed in the currency the cardmember agreed to be billed in?
- Only if the seller contests outside Amex's list: if it was converted, did the cardmember choose that?
Evidence that answers it
“Where it goes” uses the names Stripe's and Square's APIs give each piece of evidence, which are the names Upheld uses in your packet. Nothing is sent without your approval; where Upheld can't send it for you, you submit it yourself. In Stripe's Dashboard, choose the matching type for each file or text field. In Square's, add it when Square asks you to “upload any additional evidence specific to your service type”.
| Evidence | When it counts | How to show it | Where it goes | For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Refund or credit already issued | If the payment was already refunded (Amex's only listed response). | Refund date, amount, and reference. | Stripe: Uncategorized fileSquare: Generic evidence | Every seller |
| Receipt or invoice | Showing the currency, which answers the issuer's question but isn't on Amex's list. | The receipt or invoice sent to the customer. | Stripe: ReceiptSquare: Receipt | Every seller |
| Terms accepted at checkout | Showing the currency shown and chosen, which answers the issuer's question but isn't on Amex's list. | A screenshot of the checkout page as it was at the time of purchase, showing the terms and the checkbox or statement, plus the acceptance timestamp if recorded. | Stripe: Refund policy disclosure, Cancellation policy disclosure or Uncategorized fileSquare: Purchase acknowledgement | Every seller |
| Messages with the customer | If the cardholder has withdrawn the dispute. | The relevant messages only, dated, with the key lines highlighted or quoted in the response. | Stripe: Customer communicationSquare: Cardholder communication | Every seller |
What doesn't help
- Proof of delivery alone. The question is how the payment was processed.
American Express's rules for P23
- P23 covers a charge submitted in a different currency from the one on the record of charge. Checked against American Express, How to Manage and Help Prevent Disputes (US disputes reference guide, version 2024PROP, revised December 2024), chargeback code P23; read 2026-10-27. Amex's only listed response is a credit that offsets the charge.
Common mistakes with American Express P23
- Not stating what the payment processor's records show.
Should you fight it?
Amex's guide lists only one response to P23, a credit that offsets the charge. If you already refunded the payment, send the refund record. Without a refund, accepting is usually right: currency records answer the issuer's questions but aren't on Amex's list. Accept it when any of these is true:
- The payment hasn't already been refunded: Amex's only listed response is a credit that offsets the charge.
- The charge was in a different currency from the receipt.
If you accept, don't refund as well: once it's a chargeback the money has already gone back to the customer, so a refund would pay them twice.
A dispute counts against your account whether you win or lose. To see the chance of winning at which fighting pays on your amount, try the fight-or-accept calculator; to compare what you keep with each tool, the fee calculator.
How to prevent the next one
- Show prices in one currency at checkout, and don't convert a customer's currency without offering the choice.
Deadlines and fees
| Platform | Deadline | Fees |
|---|---|---|
| Stripe (US)Checked 2026-10-21 | Respond by the due date on the dispute in your Stripe Dashboard. It's usually 7 to 21 days, depending on the card network. | $15 when the dispute arrives, which isn't returned. $15 more when you respond, returned only if you win in full.Stripe's Smart Disputes waives the $15 response fee and takes 30% of the disputed amount when you win. |
| SquareChecked 2026-10-21 | Seven days from Square's first email about the dispute. | No fees for dispute management on chargebacks: Square covers the fee for disputes you challenge together. |
| Shopify Payments (US)Checked 2026-10-21 | Respond by the evidence due date in your Shopify admin. It's usually 7 to 21 days. | $15 per chargeback, returned if you win. |
A worked example (made up)
You sell an online photography course priced in US dollars, and your checkout shows the price only in US dollars. A buyer in Canada pays $249 on March 4. On March 18 they write that they expected to pay in Canadian dollars, and on March 20 you refund the full $249 to their card. In April the issuer files a P23 anyway, saying the payment was processed in the wrong currency.
The response would attach:
- Exhibit A: the refund record: $249.00 credited to the same card on March 20.
- Exhibit B: the payment processor's history for the payment: the $249.00 charge on March 4 and the full refund against it on March 20, before the chargeback.
- Exhibit C: the receipt: $249.00 in US dollars, March 4, for the photography course.
A sample response letter (made up)
For the example above. It's laid out the way Upheld drafts a response: one part for each thing the bank checks, strongest evidence first, each pointing to its exhibit. Yours should state only what your own records show.
We respond to this dispute, American Express reason code P23, for $249.00 charged on March 4 for an online photography course. The cardmember was refunded the full amount on March 20, before this chargeback was raised.
The cardmember has already been credited the full $249.00, to the same card, on March 20 (Exhibit A): a credit that offsets the charge. Our processor's history shows the charge and the full refund against it (Exhibit B).
The payment was processed in US dollars, the currency the course was sold in, as the receipt shows (Exhibit C).
The charge has already been offset by a full credit. We ask that this P23 chargeback be reversed.
Questions people ask
What is an Amex P23 currency discrepancy chargeback?
American Express's code for a charge submitted in a different currency from the one on the record of charge, as its US disputes guide describes it.
What response does Amex list for a P23?
Its US disputes guide lists only one: a credit that offsets the charge. Records showing the charge was in the sale's currency answer the issuer's questions, but they aren't a response Amex lists.
Our checkout converted the price into the buyer's currency. What does the issuer look at?
Whether the cardmember chose the conversion. Send the checkout record showing the currency shown and the one chosen, though Amex's only listed response is a credit. Going forward, show prices in one currency and don't convert a customer's currency without offering the choice.
Will proof the course was delivered help with a P23?
Not on its own. A P23 asks which currency the payment was processed in, not whether the buyer got the course.
Draft yours free
Answer a few questions and get a draft, an evidence checklist and an honest read on whether to fight. Free account, no card.
Not sure what your notice says? Decode it first.