Amex C31 — Goods/Services Not as Described

Amex C31: the cardmember says the goods or services weren't as described

By · Updated

Checked by three automated reviewers (facts against the playbook, search, and our rules), then approved by the author on .

American Express C31 means the cardmember says the goods or services weren't as described. It turns on your written description at the time of sale against what you delivered; Amex also lists proof they agreed to take it as is, or that you offered a repair or replacement. If it really differed from the listing, accept.

Start a free draft

What decides an Amex C31

The written description, as it was at the sale
Amex's first listed response is proof refuting that the written description differs from what the cardmember received. Use the sales page or agreement as it stood at the purchase: a page captured after it was edited doesn't help, and nor does saying the cardmember is wrong about quality without it.
Agreement to take it as provided, or "as is"
Amex lists proof the cardmember agreed to accept the goods or services as provided, or "as is", as a response of its own, alongside proof that what you delivered matched the description at purchase, shown with photos or emails.
Your answer to the complaint
The bank checks whether you responded to the complaint and offered a fix, replacement or return, and Amex lists proof of an attempt to repair or replace.
A return outside your policy
If the goods came back, Amex lists proof the cardmember didn't follow a clearly documented cancellation or return policy. If they returned it and you didn't refund it, accept.
For a service, the agreed scope
When the cardmember paid for a service, the signed agreement setting out its scope is the written description to compare, and your record of what was delivered shows what they received. For a digital product, attach a log of the cardmember's use showing it was substantial.

The bank's test

The bank checks:

  1. How the product or service was described at the time of sale, compared with what was delivered.
  2. Whether the seller responded to the complaint and offered a fix, replacement, or return.
  3. For goods, whether the customer tried to return them.

Evidence that answers it

“Where it goes” uses the names Stripe's and Square's APIs give each piece of evidence, which are the names Upheld uses in your packet. Nothing is sent without your approval; where Upheld can't send it for you, you submit it yourself. In Stripe's Dashboard, choose the matching type for each file or text field. In Square's, add it when Square asks you to “upload any additional evidence specific to your service type”.

Evidence for American Express C31, by kind of business
EvidenceWhen it countsHow to show itWhere it goesFor
Product or service as described at saleWhat the customer was told they were buying, captured as it was at the time of sale.A capture of the sales page, listing, or proposal as it was at the time of purchase, plus a one-paragraph plain description.Stripe: Product description or Uncategorized fileSquare: Product or service descriptionEvery seller
Signed contract or agreementShowing the agreed scope.The signed document with the signature and the relevant clauses marked.Stripe: Customer signature or Service documentationSquare: Purchase acknowledgementServices
Service deliveredShowing what was delivered.Dates of service with proof: calendar invites and attendance, call records, delivered files, project sign-off.Stripe: Service date or Service documentationSquare: Service received documentationServices
Messages with the customerShowing the seller's response and any offer to fix or replace.The relevant messages only, dated, with the key lines highlighted or quoted in the response.Stripe: Customer communicationSquare: Cardholder communicationEvery seller
Access and usage logShowing substantial use.Dated list of activity tied to the customer's account: first and last login, count of sessions, what was viewed or downloaded. A short summary first, then the export.Stripe: Access activity logSquare: Online or app access logCourses, memberships, digital products
Proof of deliveryThe goods arrived at the customer's address.The carrier's delivery record showing date, address, and any signature or photo.Stripe: Shipping documentationSquare: Proof of delivery documentationOnline stores
Return statusWhether the goods were returned, and whether the return followed the policy: no return received, or a return outside the policy.State whether a return was received, when, and in what condition, with any return tracking.Stripe: Refund refusal explanation or Uncategorized fileSquare: Generic evidenceOnline stores
Refund or return policyWhat the customer was entitled to, and that this situation falls outside it.The policy as it read at the time of purchase, with the relevant clause quoted, plus how it was shown to the customer.Stripe: Refund policy, Refund policy disclosure or Refund refusal explanationSquare: Cancellation or refund documentationEvery seller
Terms accepted at checkoutThe customer saw and agreed to the terms (refund, cancellation, recurring billing) when they paid.A screenshot of the checkout page as it was at the time of purchase, showing the terms and the checkbox or statement, plus the acceptance timestamp if recorded.Stripe: Refund policy disclosure, Cancellation policy disclosure or Uncategorized fileSquare: Purchase acknowledgementEvery seller

Start a free draft

What doesn't help

  • Saying the customer is wrong about quality without evidence of what was promised and delivered.
  • A sales page captured after it was edited.
  • A "no refunds" policy when the item really was defective.

American Express's rules for C31

  • Amex's listed responses: proof refuting that the written description differs from what was received; proof the goods or services matched the description at purchase (photos, emails); proof the cardmember agreed to accept them as provided or "as is"; proof of an attempt to repair or replace; if returned, proof the cardmember didn't follow a clearly documented cancellation or return policy; or a credit that offsets it. Source: American Express, How to Manage and Help Prevent Disputes (US disputes reference guide, version 2024PROP, revised December 2024), chargeback code C31; read 2026-10-27.
  • Amex now files C31 as ISO 4553 (not as described or defective). From 24 April 2027 it can't be used for the quality of food at a restaurant. Source: American Express, Merchant Rules: Notification of Changes (October 2026), section 6.4; read 2026-10-27. The full Merchant Rules weren't checked.
  • Amex C32 (damaged or defective) shares this Stripe category, as do legacy codes 024, 059, and 063.

Common mistakes with American Express C31

  • Not answering the specific complaint the customer made.
  • Ignoring the customer before the dispute, then arguing afterwards.
  • Attaching a description that doesn't match the version the customer bought.

Should you fight it?

Fight it when a description captured at the time of sale, or the agreement setting out the scope, matches what you delivered, and you answered the complaint with an offer to fix, replace or take it back. For a service, set the agreed scope beside your record of what was delivered and when. Accept it when any of these is true:

  • The item really was defective or different from the listing.
  • The customer returned it and wasn't refunded.
  • The seller never answered the customer's complaint.

If you accept, don't refund as well: once it's a chargeback the money has already gone back to the customer, so a refund would pay them twice.

A dispute counts against your account whether you win or lose. To see the chance of winning at which fighting pays on your amount, try the fight-or-accept calculator; to compare what you keep with each tool, the fee calculator.

How to prevent the next one

  • Keep listings accurate and save a dated copy of the sales page whenever it changes.
  • Answer complaints in writing quickly, and offer a fix, replacement, or return.
  • Show the return and refund policy at checkout.

Deadlines and fees

Deadlines and fees by platform
PlatformDeadlineFees
Stripe (US)Checked 2026-10-21Respond by the due date on the dispute in your Stripe Dashboard. It's usually 7 to 21 days, depending on the card network.$15 when the dispute arrives, which isn't returned. $15 more when you respond, returned only if you win in full.Stripe's Smart Disputes waives the $15 response fee and takes 30% of the disputed amount when you win.
SquareChecked 2026-10-21Seven days from Square's first email about the dispute.No fees for dispute management on chargebacks: Square covers the fee for disputes you challenge together.
Shopify Payments (US)Checked 2026-10-21Respond by the evidence due date in your Shopify admin. It's usually 7 to 21 days.$15 per chargeback, returned if you win.

A worked example (made up)

You sell brand design packages online. The package page and the agreement each client signs list three logo concepts, two rounds of revisions and final files; a brand style guide is a separate package. A client pays $900 with an Amex card on May 5 and signs the agreement. You send concepts on May 19, revisions on May 26 and June 2, and final files on June 4. On June 6 they email that they expected a style guide. You reply on June 7 that it isn't in the package and offer a third round of revisions at no charge. They don't reply, and file a C31 on June 20.

The response would attach:

  1. Exhibit A: the package page as captured on May 5: three logo concepts, two revision rounds and final files, with the style guide sold separately.
  2. Exhibit B: the agreement the client signed on May 5, setting out the same scope.
  3. Exhibit C: the delivery record: concepts on May 19, revisions on May 26 and June 2, final files on June 4.
  4. Exhibit D: the client's email of June 6 and our reply of June 7 offering a third round of revisions at no charge, with no answer after it.

A sample response letter (made up)

For the example above. It's laid out the way Upheld drafts a response: one part for each thing the bank checks, strongest evidence first, each pointing to its exhibit. Yours should state only what your own records show.

We contest this dispute, American Express reason code C31, for $900.00 charged on May 5 for a brand design package. What we delivered matches the package as described at purchase, and when the client raised a concern we offered a further round of revisions at no charge.

The written description matches what the client received. Our package page on May 5 listed three logo concepts, two rounds of revisions and final files, and said a brand style guide is sold separately (Exhibit A). The agreement the client signed that day sets out the same scope (Exhibit B). We delivered each part: concepts on May 19, revisions on May 26 and June 2, and final files on June 4 (Exhibit C).

We answered the complaint and offered a fix. The client wrote on June 6 that they expected a style guide. We replied on June 7 that it is not part of the package and offered a third round of revisions at no charge; the client did not reply (Exhibit D).

The package was delivered as described and as agreed, and our offer to revise it further went unanswered. We ask that the dispute be decided in our favor.

Questions people ask

What's the difference between Amex C31 and C32?

C31 is for goods or services the cardmember says weren't as described; C32 is for goods or services that arrived damaged or defective. Stripe puts both in the same category, as it does the legacy codes 024, 059 and 063, so read the network code on the notice.

We sold it "as is". Does that answer a C31?

It can: Amex lists proof the cardmember agreed to accept the goods or services as provided, or "as is", as one of its responses. Attach what they agreed to and when. A "no refunds" policy doesn't help when the item really was defective.

Is Amex C31 the same as ISO code 4553?

Amex now files C31 as ISO 4553, not as described or defective, according to its October 2026 notification of changes to its Merchant Rules. The same notice says that from 24 April 2027 C31 can't be used for the quality of food at a restaurant.

A client says our service wasn't what we described. What do we attach?

The agreement that set out the scope, your sales page as it was at purchase, and a dated record of what you delivered. Add your reply to the complaint and any offer to fix it, since Amex lists an attempt to repair or replace as a response.

We updated our sales page after the order. Which version do we send for a C31?

The version the cardmember saw when they bought. The bank compares the description at the time of sale with what was delivered, so a capture made after your edit doesn't help, and sending a newer version than the one bought is a common mistake. Saving a dated copy of the page whenever it changes means you have the right one.

Draft yours free

Answer a few questions and get a draft, an evidence checklist and an honest read on whether to fight. Free account, no card.

Not sure what your notice says? Decode it first.

Start a free draft