Comparison

ChargePay alternative: both charge a flat price, one waits for your yes

Facts about ChargePay checked 2026-11-17, from its own site. Sources are at the end.

ChargePay and Upheld have the same pricing idea: a flat fee and no share of what you win. ChargePay's plans run from $19.99 a month with unlimited chargebacks, set by your Shopify plan, and its AI agent answers each one on its own. Upheld is $9 a draft or from $29 a month, works for sellers on Stripe and Square whether or not they use Shopify, and sends nothing until you approve it.

Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.

Upheld today: Connect Stripe (US businesses) and disputes arrive with their deadlines, and Upheld sends the response you approve to Stripe. Square opens next; Shopify is in progress. From anywhere else, you enter a dispute by hand (paste the notice or upload a screenshot of it) and download the finished packet to submit in your platform's dashboard. Prices: $9 a draft, or $29, $59 or $99 a month for 15, 60 or unlimited drafts. Your first 3 drafts are free. Every draft counts, drafting a dispute again included; editing the letter is free.

ChargePay and Upheld, side by side

ChargePayUpheld
Price$19.99, $39.99, $79.99 or $99.99 a month, matching your Shopify plan, each with "Unlimited chargebacks"; 20% off yearly ($191.90 a year on Basic); a 7-day trial. It says "there are no additional charges for fighting or winning chargebacks with AI."$9 a draft, or from $29 a month. Nothing more when you win.
Who sends the responseIts "autonomous AI Agent" fights each chargeback; "AI-powered representments are created automatically for each new chargeback." We found no step on its pricing page, home page or App Store listing where you review a response before it goes.You approve each response; nothing is sent before that.
PlatformsA Shopify app with the Built for Shopify badge, working with Shopify Payments, Stripe, PayPal, Braintree, Klarna, Affirm and Afterpay.Stripe today, for US businesses: disputes arrive with their deadlines, and the response you approve is sent to Stripe. Square opens next; Shopify is in progress. Disputes from anywhere else are entered by hand.
Beyond responsesFraud screening, order validation, and alerts ($19 per RDR or CDRN alert, $29 per Ethoca alert).With Stripe connected, account health: your dispute rate against Stripe's threshold. No pre-dispute alerts or fraud screening.

When ChargePay is the better choice, and when Upheld is

ChargePay

  • You run a Shopify store with many disputes: its unlimited plan starts at $19.99 a month.
  • You want every chargeback answered with no time from you.
  • You want alerts and fraud screening in the same app.
  • You want an app Shopify has badged Built for Shopify.

Upheld

  • You don't sell through Shopify: you take payments on Stripe or Square directly.
  • You want to read and approve every response before it goes.
  • You sell courses, coaching, memberships or services, and want the questions and evidence list built for that kind of dispute.

Questions for what you sell

The bank's test depends on the dispute's reason, and the evidence that passes it depends on what you sell. Upheld asks:

  • Courses and coaching: where the program is hosted (Kajabi, Teachable, Thinkific, Skool, Circle or your own site), how much of it the buyer used, and what your refund terms said when they bought.
  • Memberships and subscriptions: how members can cancel, whether a trial was followed by a reminder before the first full charge, and whether renewal receipts say how to cancel.
  • Physical goods: the carrier's proof of delivery, and where the order was shipped compared with the card's billing address.
  • Services billed online: what the client agreed to before paying, and how much of the agreed work was delivered.

ChargePay: questions sellers ask

Is ChargePay cheaper than Upheld?

Often, yes. ChargePay is unlimited from $19.99 a month, set by your Shopify plan. After its 3 free drafts, Upheld is $9 a draft, so against that lowest plan it costs less only up to 2 paid drafts a month; from 3, ChargePay costs less. ChargePay's higher plans, up to $99.99, move that point up. Upheld's Starter is $29 for 15 drafts. Upheld is priced for the draft it writes, not to be the cheapest.

Which ChargePay plan would I pay, and where does each one pass Upheld?

ChargePay's plan follows your Shopify plan, not how many disputes you get. On Shopify Basic it's $19.99 a month, so it costs less than Upheld's $9 drafts from 3 paid drafts a month. On Shopify Grow it's $39.99 a month, so it costs less than Upheld's $9 drafts from 5 paid drafts a month. On Shopify Advanced it's $79.99 a month, so it costs less than Upheld's $9 drafts from 9 paid drafts a month. On Shopify Plus it's $99.99 a month, so it costs less than Upheld's $9 drafts from 12 paid drafts a month. Below those counts, paying Upheld per draft costs less, and a month with no disputes costs nothing.

Can I approve ChargePay's responses before they're sent?

Its own pages describe sending on its own: its AI "automatically creates and submits data-backed evidence for every case". We found no review or approval step on its pricing page, home page or App Store listing, so ask ChargePay if you need one. Upheld never sends without your approval: you read the draft, change what you want, and approve it. Then Upheld sends it to Stripe for a connected Stripe account; elsewhere, you submit it yourself.

What does ChargePay charge beyond the plan?

Its alerts, which are optional: $19 per RDR or CDRN alert and $29 per Ethoca alert, per its App Store listing. Fighting and winning add nothing. Upheld has no alerts to add.

Can I use Upheld for a Shopify Payments chargeback?

Yes, by hand for now. Type in the dispute from your Shopify admin, answer the questions for what you sell, and Upheld writes the response and lists the evidence to attach. You paste it into the dispute in Shopify and submit it there. Connecting Shopify, so disputes arrive on their own, is in progress.

Does Upheld fight every dispute?

No. It rates each case strong, moderate or weak, and when a case is weak it says so and offers accepting as an option. Accepting costs nothing more on Upheld.

Try it on a dispute

Draft a response free: answer a few questions and get a letter built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach.