Comparison
Redo Reclaim alternative: for disputes outside a Shopify store
Facts about Redo checked 2026-10-28, from its own site. Sources are at the end.
If you run a Shopify store, Redo's Reclaim may be the cheapest option there is: its product pages say "$0 install fee, $0 success fee", and that you don't need any other Redo product. It finds the dispute, builds the evidence and files before the deadline. Redo's own help center gives a different price, a fee of 25% of recovered revenue, so check with Redo which applies to you. Upheld is for sellers it doesn't cover: courses, memberships and services on Stripe or Square, with a draft you approve before anything is sent.
Draft my response free3 free drafts, no card. Nothing is sent without your approval.
Upheld today: Connect Stripe (US businesses) and disputes arrive with their deadlines, and Upheld sends the response you approve to Stripe. Square opens next; Shopify is in progress. From anywhere else, you enter a dispute by hand (paste the notice or upload a screenshot of it) and download the finished packet to submit in your platform's dashboard. Prices: $9 a draft, or $29, $59 or $99 a month for 15, 60 or unlimited drafts. Your first 3 drafts are free. Every draft counts, drafting a dispute again included; editing the letter is free.
Redo and Upheld, side by side
| Redo | Upheld | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Its product pages: "$0 install fee, $0 success fee" and "Recovery stays free forever, whether or not you use anything else from Redo". Its help center's pricing article (last updated 13 March 2026) gives a fee of 25% of recovered revenue, "only on disputes we win." | $9 a draft, or from $29 a month. Nothing more when you win. |
| Who sends the response | Reclaim "drafts the response, and files before the bank's deadline"; it shows the evidence package in your dashboard first, and you can add to it. | You approve each response; nothing is sent before that. |
| Who it's for | "Shopify merchants on Stripe, PayPal, and Shopify Payments". | Sellers on Stripe or Square, on Shopify or not, and any dispute entered by hand. |
| Beyond responses | Resolve, to prevent avoidable disputes, and Alerts ($15 per Visa RDR or CDRN alert, $24 per Ethoca alert); returns, support and checkout tools for Shopify. | With Stripe connected, account health: your dispute rate against Stripe's threshold. No pre-dispute alerts. |
When Redo is the better choice, and when Upheld is
Redo
- You run a Shopify store and Reclaim's $0 price applies to you.
- You want disputes filed automatically, with a look at the evidence before it goes.
- You already use Redo for returns or support.
Upheld
- You don't sell through Shopify: you take payments on Stripe or Square directly.
- You sell courses, coaching, memberships or services, where the evidence is progress, terms and delivery of the work, not a shipment.
- You want to approve every response, and to be told plainly when a case isn't worth fighting.
Questions for what you sell
The bank's test depends on the dispute's reason, and the evidence that passes it depends on what you sell. Upheld asks:
- Courses and coaching: where the program is hosted (Kajabi, Teachable, Thinkific, Skool, Circle or your own site), how much of it the buyer used, and what your refund terms said when they bought.
- Memberships and subscriptions: how members can cancel, whether a trial was followed by a reminder before the first full charge, and whether renewal receipts say how to cancel.
- Physical goods: the carrier's proof of delivery, and where the order was shipped compared with the card's billing address.
- Services billed online: what the client agreed to before paying, and how much of the agreed work was delivered.
Redo: questions sellers ask
Is Redo's Reclaim really free?
Its product pages say so: "$0 install fee, $0 success fee". Its help center's pricing article, read the same day (2026-10-28), gives a fee of 25% of recovered revenue, "only on disputes we win." Ask Redo which applies to your store before relying on either.
Does Upheld work with Shopify?
Not connected yet: you enter a Shopify chargeback by hand, Upheld drafts the response, and you add it as evidence in your Shopify admin.
Try it on a dispute
Draft a response free: answer a few questions and get a letter built only from your answers, with the evidence to attach.